top of page
Search

The Employee Experience and the Business Reality

Writer: Dean Johnston
Dean Johnston
5 days ago
10 min read

The organisation we believe we have created.


Picture a leadership team at the close of a strong year. They have refreshed the company values, launched a wellbeing policy and promised that people sit at the heart of the strategy. The town hall goes well. The slides look sharp, and the applause is genuine.

Three weeks later, a team member in operations asks for two days of leave during month-end. Her manager tells her it is not a good time. She rereads the wellbeing policy on the intranet, closes the page and returns to her desk.


Nobody in that story acted with bad intent. The leadership team meant every word, and the manager faced real targets. Yet the employee has just learned something no policy document could teach her: what the organisation truly values when pressure arrives.


That moment captures the theme of this week's chapter. Every organisation holds a view of the business it wants to be. Its people experience the business it actually is.

This scenario is illustrative. It does not describe any specific organisation.


Are we managing the organisation we believe we have created, or the organisation that actually exists?


Why this matters now

Leaders have always faced this tension, but the cost of ignoring it is rising. Gallup's State of the Global Workplace: 2026 report found that global employee engagement fell to 20% in 2025, its lowest level since 2020. Gallup estimates the cost to the global economy at roughly $10 trillion in lost productivity.


Those figures do not prove that every disengaged employee works inside a misaligned organisation. They do suggest that the everyday working experience is not delivering what many organisations intend.


Leaders also have less margin for error. Skills shortages, technology change and economic pressure all demand more discretionary effort from people. In my experience, discretionary effort follows trust, and trust follows consistency.


The problem beneath the problem

When engagement dips, most organisations reach for a programme. They launch another survey, redesign the values or add a recognition scheme. These tools have value, but they often treat the symptom.


The deeper problem lies in how organisations measure themselves. We tend to evaluate ourselves through the systems we have introduced, rather than through the experiences those systems create. A policy exists, a review took place, and a survey went out.


None of those facts, on their own, shows that the intended outcome arrived. A completed appraisal tells you a form was submitted. It does not tell you whether the conversation was honest, fair or useful.


Intention and experience

Organisational intention is what a business says it wants to achieve and the principles it communicates. Organisational experience is what happens when those intentions meet every day operational reality. The two should reinforce each other, yet we cannot simply assume that they do.


Take wellbeing as an example. An organisation publishes a policy, promotes work-life balance and asks managers to support their teams. Meanwhile, employees regularly work beyond reasonable expectations, managers discourage leave in busy periods, and nobody feels safe admitting that their workload has become unmanageable.


The policy exists, and the intention is real. The experience tells a different story. The same pattern appears in accountability, leadership development, recognition, collaboration and communication.



The Organisational Alignment Gap

I find it useful to examine this distance through a concept I call The Organisational Alignment Gap. It describes the space between what an organisation intends, communicates and formally establishes, and what employees experience through leadership behaviour, management practice and everyday operations.

It is not a measure of satisfaction or culture. It asks a more direct question: do the organisation's stated commitments show up in its actual behaviour?


The gap can open across six dimensions, and each one deserves a candid look.


•     Leadership behaviour. What leaders say about expectations can differ from the behaviour employees observe.

•     Organisational values. Values in corporate communication may not shape decisions, relationships or the treatment of people.

•     Management practices. Policies set one standard, while individual managers interpret and apply them differently.

•     Decision-making authority. Employees hear encouragement to show initiative, yet work within structures that limit meaningful decisions.

•     Performance expectations. Organisations demand results without checking whether people have the capability, resources and support to deliver them.

•     Employee voice. Businesses promote open communication but fail to show that feedback is heard, considered and acted upon.


These dimensions connect. A leader who says one thing and does another weakens trust in the values, the policies and the feedback channels all at once.


So an organisation cannot assume alignment because its structures look right on paper. Alignment must be experienced, observed and demonstrated.


When values become contradictions

Leaders establish values with good intentions. Values give people a shared reference point and signal what matters. They only become meaningful when they influence decisions.


An organisation may name trust as a core value, yet monitor its people constantly and deny them reasonable judgement. It may call respect fundamental, yet allow managers to dismiss concerns as routine. It may champion teamwork, yet reward individual competition at the expense of collaboration.


This creates a credibility problem. Employees do not judge values through formal communication. They judge them through repeated experience, and over time the distance between what an organisation says and what it does shapes their confidence in leadership, their willingness to contribute and their identification with its goals.


What the research says

A 2026 study by Zara Whysall and Nadia Kougiannou, published in Employee Relations: The International Journal, gives part of this problem a name. The authors define HR whitewashing as symbolic policy signalling in the HR domain that is not matched by substantive behavioural or structural change. They treat it as a perceptual phenomenon, rooted in how employees experience gaps between values and practice.


The study draws on cross-sectional survey data from 1,178 employees in UK organisations. Over half of respondents reported inconsistencies between wellbeing policies and observed behaviour, and over two-fifths reported inconsistencies with diversity, equity and inclusion policy. The authors also found that perceived alignment of leadership behaviour, and of hiring and promotion practices, with espoused values was strongly associated with perceived cultural alignment.


We should read these findings with care. The study is cross-sectional and rests on employee perceptions, so it shows association rather than cause. It also describes UK organisations. Even so, it offers a rigorous, contemporary signal that employees notice when commitments and conduct drift apart.


A note on terms. HR whitewashing is the authors' concept, and it focuses on HR policy commitments. The Organisational Alignment Gap, as I use it here, is a broader working lens that also covers leadership behaviour, decision rights and performance expectations. I present it as a developing Elevyx Group idea, not as a validated model.


Values cannot be sustained through communication alone. They require consistent demonstration.

Dean Johnston



The human, leadership and business dimensions


The human dimension

People read their organisation through daily signals. When they see a gap between promise and practice, their confidence weakens quietly. They stop raising concerns, stop suggesting improvements and start protecting themselves.


The leadership dimension

Employee experience is not simply an HR initiative. Surveys, wellbeing programmes and recognition events can help, but they cannot compensate indefinitely for inconsistent management behaviour. The everyday relationship between an employee and their manager carries enormous weight.


Managers translate priorities into instructions, allocate work, set expectations and resolve problems. Their behaviour becomes the most visible expression of the culture. Consider a manager who tells people to take ownership but challenges every decision that differs from their own preference. The stated expectation is independence. The experienced reality is restriction.


Or consider a business that invites operational concerns but responds defensively when those concerns touch senior decisions. The stated expectation is openness. The experienced reality is caution.


None of this means managers should avoid oversight, challenge or difficult conversations. Good management needs all three. The question is whether management practice matches the behaviour the organisation says it wants.


The business dimension

The Alignment Gap is not only an employee relations concern. It carries operational and commercial consequences, although their size will vary with the nature of the business, its workforce and its management capability. Leaders should watch for five in particular.


•     Reduced employee confidence. Repeated inconsistency between communication and action weakens trust in leadership commitments.

•     Lower willingness to contribute. People who believe their input will be ignored raise fewer concerns and offer fewer improvements.

•     Inconsistent performance. When expectations, authority and practice do not align, people struggle to know what truly matters.

•     Retention challenges. A gap between the experience promised at recruitment and the reality of the job can influence the decision to stay.

•     Operational inefficiency. Conflicting instructions, unclear responsibilities and needless approvals cause delay and duplicated effort.

I would not assume that all five exist in every organisation. I would treat them as hypotheses worth testing.



A South African perspective

South African leaders face this challenge under particular pressure. Cost-of-living strain and rapid technology change raise the stakes in every employment relationship, and the margin for lost trust is thin.


ADP Research's People at Work 2026 report found that 27% of workers in South Africa were fully engaged in 2025. ADP's commentary describes South Africa as one of the world's stronger markets for engagement, while warning employers not to take that position for granted. ADP and Gallup measure engagement differently, so their figures are not directly comparable.


Mercer's Global Talent Trends 2026 study in South Africa surveyed 500 employees and 50 C-suite executives. As reported by ITWeb, 88% of executives believe their organisations foster trust, while 68% of employees agree that trust exists among colleagues. The two questions differ in framing, so I read this as a signal rather than a precise comparison.

The same study found that South African employees rank communication (71%) and empathy (67%) as the most critical leadership traits during disruption. Both are behaviours, not policies.


The GIBS and October Health Workplace Wellbeing Index points in a related direction. Its authors describe a strategic blind spot: employees want culture and leadership behaviours that genuinely support wellbeing, while many organisations continue to rely on traditional wellness programmes. That is the Alignment Gap in action.



A global perspective


Gallup's data adds a striking detail. Engagement among non-manager roles has stayed largely flat over three years, while manager engagement has fallen from 31% in 2022 to 22% in 2025. The largest single drop came between 2024 and 2025, when it fell five points from 27% to 22%. Gallup links much of the recent global decline to that fall.


This matters for our theme. Managers carry the Alignment Gap on their shoulders, because they translate organisational promises into daily experience. When managers disengage, the promise reaches employees weakened or not at all. Earlier Gallup analysis, as widely reported, attributes roughly 70% of the variance in team engagement to the direct manager.

There is encouraging news. Gallup found that in best-practice organisations, 79% of managers were engaged, nearly four times the global average. Gallup also stresses that declining manager engagement is not inevitable.


I must be careful here. Gallup measures engagement, not alignment, and I am not claiming that engagement scores prove an alignment gap. I am suggesting that the manager layer, where intention meets experience, deserves the closest attention.



What organisations get wrong


Listening is not the same as understanding

Most organisations collect feedback. They run engagement surveys, hold departmental meetings, schedule performance discussions and invite consultation. These mechanisms provide valuable information. Yet collecting feedback does not mean the organisation understands what people describe, and asking for opinions does not show a willingness to respond.


The Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (CIPD) describes employee voice as a contributor to trust, innovation, productivity and organisational improvement. It recognises individual and collective forms of voice, and it states that organisations should have meaningful policies and practices that enable people to raise concerns. It also notes that more needs to be done so that more individuals feel confident and safe using their voice.


So listening has two forms: an activity and a management responsibility. When employees raise the same concerns repeatedly and see no consideration or action, the organisation teaches them that speaking up makes little difference. That lesson spreads fast.

Responding does not mean agreeing. Commercial, operational and regulatory realities legitimately limit what an organisation can do. Explaining a decision, however, is part of responsible leadership. People can accept a "no" they understand far more readily than a silence they cannot interpret.


Redefining instead of changing

Some organisations answer a gap by rewriting the values or adding more policy. There is little point in redefining values if daily behaviour stays the same. New policies and engagement initiatives will not solve problems that originate in leadership behaviour, decision structures or operational practice.



What leaders should consider

To understand the distance between intended culture and lived experience, we must look beyond policy and stated values. I suggest five areas of investigation.


1.     What does the organisation communicate? Review the values, expectations, policies and commitments employees hear. Establish what the organisation believes it stands for and what it expects people to experience.

2.    What do leaders actually demonstrate? Test whether decisions, communication and everyday behaviour consistently reflect those commitments.

3.    What do employees actually experience? Explore how people describe their environment, relationships, management practices and opportunities. Use more than one feedback mechanism.

4.    Where do the contradictions sit? Compare intention with observed practice and experience. Look for recurring patterns rather than treating each concern as an isolated incident.

5.    What must change? Decide which issues need leadership intervention, management development, policy review, better communication or operational redesign.


The purpose is not to assign blame. It is to build a more accurate picture of the organisation and the conditions shaping its performance. Human capital management has a real contribution to make here, because it connects employee experience, organisational behaviour and business priorities.


Ethics matter in this work. Leaders should ask for honest views only when they are prepared to hear them, protect confidentiality and explain what will change. Inviting candour and then penalising it would widen the gap faster than silence ever could.


Finally, leaders must accept that the experience may reveal things they have not fully recognised. That is not a failure of leadership. It is an opportunity for understanding, and it only becomes valuable when insight turns into action.



The Decision Room


Questions for your next leadership conversation

1.     If a new employee shadowed your leadership team for a month, which of your stated values would they see in action, and which would they struggle to find?

2.    Where do your managers face a choice between your stated commitments and your operational targets, and what do they usually decide?

3.    When did your organisation last change something because an employee raised a concern, and did you tell people it happened?

4.    Which of the six dimensions of the Alignment Gap would your people say is widest today, and how do you know?

5.    What is one decision you could make this month that would visibly close a gap?

 

Final author reflection

Organisations rarely lose trust through one dramatic failure. They lose it through a series of small moments when the stated priority gave way to the urgent one. Those same moments are where trust can be rebuilt, one consistent decision at a time.


People rarely remember what an organisation promised. They remember what it did when keeping the promise became inconvenient.

Dean Johnston


The question is not simply whether your organisation has defined the culture it wants. The question is whether its people recognise that culture in the organisation they experience every day.

 
 
 

Comments


Book a Consultation

 

Whether you are looking to strengthen leadership, improve organisational performance or enhance employee wellbeing, we are ready to help.

 

Let's start a conversation about how Elevyx Group can support your organisation's goals and create lasting impact. Book Your Consultation Today

​

Contact: Dean Johnston

Email: dean@elevyxgroup.com

Cell: +27 60 392 2616

​

 

© 2026 by Elevyx Group - HR Managed Services I Executive Consulting I Mental Health I Coaching, Wellness and Therapy. Powered and secured by Wix 

 

bottom of page